V2, last updated November 2019
These categories represent the entirety of information that the NewsQ Database collects or seeks to collect. This data might be incorporated into algorithms that seek to support quality journalism in news feeds and search results.
A partial draft of NewsQ Signals can be found here.
A previous version of the classes for the project can be found in this blog post.
Signal source and signal class
Knowing the source of data signal related to news sites may impact evaluation of the data (class) itself. While there are strong links between some of the sources and classes, they are not always the same. Consider these examples:
● Editorial activity, such as a corrections policy, may be self-reported by the publisher and/or confirmed by a third-party.
● An award provided by an external organization, may be provided directly on their organization’s website or collected through a mention on the publisher’s own site (self-reported.)
Each unique signal in the aggregator is always associated with one source category and one class category.
These categories are continually evolving, and feedback is welcome.
A. Signal source
- Third-party reported
B. Signal class
- Website/Domain attributes
- Publisher/Outlet attributes
- Journalistic Content
- Journalistic Behavior
- External Assessments
- External Affiliations
- Traffic and Engagement Metrics
- TBD Potential class: Revenue/Advertisment
Signal class definitions
There are seven main signal classes of information within the NewsQ database. We’ve provided the guiding question and description along with a sample of candidate signals or related information for each class. The first version of our full signal set is scheduled for release in late 2019.
What types of online information outlets are we evaluating?
The project is oriented to online news and information environments, but a number of news outlets are not only online; news agencies have a presence that often go beyond virtual spaces. Information is therefore collected related to both domains and the actual outlets.
- Organizational structure
- Media type
- Online presence
II. Journalistic Content
To what extent does the content of the online information outlet qualify as “news”?
We know in general news should contain current factual content in short formats. Describing this class is our research question of the next year.
- Accuracy-related, eg. fact-checks
- Related to “Accountability journalism”
- versus Commentary/Opinion; versus Entertainment
III. Journalistic Behavior
To what extent does the online information outlet behave according to accepted journalism ethics or express standardized journalistic behaviors?
Some indicators of quality news emerge from specific guidelines and behaviors defined in professionalized journalism.
- Editorial policy on corrections
- Editorial practice to implement corrections
How diverse is the structure and content of the information outlet?
This class accounts for the diversity of the intended audience, the product, the people responsible for the product, and the publisher.
- Outlet location
- Outlet language
- Diversity of staff
V. External assessments
How do others see the information outlet?
This class refers to external recognition or measurement of quality and trust by an organization or company.
- Publisher/Outlet awards
- Outlet Bias ratings
- Public opinion
VI. External affiliations
What official memberships or known relationships does the information outlet have that help us contextualize it better?
This class pertains to membership in professional organizations or associations as well as issues such as the Internet Research Authority.
- Member of a fact-checking network
VII. Traffic and Engagement metrics
How much traffic do these (online) information outlets experience, and what is the nature of their engagement?
Frequency of publication is likely to condition traffic and engagement, but also the relationship they establish with their audience, such as subscriptions and trackers.
- Website page views
- Outlet circulation
- Frequency of publication: eg. daily, weekender