About our project
In addition to reading about our initiative on this website, here is a one-page NewsQ Brief (April 2020).
Principles and Recommendations
Panels. In its effort to support broad constructive engagement on the question of news quality, the NewsQ Initiative hosts a series of panels. NewsQ Panels are composed of journalists, journalism experts, and technologists, and review specific cases of news ranking and recommendation to understand whether generalizable guidance or principles regarding quality journalism—interpretable both by algorithms and by journalists—might emerge.
- Values, Missions, Principles
- 2021 Panel Reports
- “Improving Representativeness in Online News Ranking and Recommendation Systems” by Sarah Gustavus Lim and Ilia Rodríguez, with contributions from Amara Aguilar, Matthew Ballinger, Russell Contreras, Megan Garvey, Shaun Griswold, Gabriella Schwarz, and Andrea Chong Brás.
- “Separating Quality News from Quality Opinion” by Kate Harloe, with contributions from Nancy Ancrum, Karen Attiah, Maria Bustillos, Sewell Chan, Elena Gooray, and Arwa Mahdawi.
- 2020 Panel Reports
- “The Local News Landscape is Broken: NewsQ Panel Review of Platform Products” by Gabriel Kahn with Meredith Clark, Al Cross, Claudia Irizarry Aponte, Mandy Jenkins, David Kroman
- “Our Opinion: Recommendations for Publishing Opinion Journalism on Digital Platforms” by Subramaniam Vincent and Patricia Lopez with David Agraz, Leona Allen Ford, Jon Allsop, Rochelle Riley, and Rebecca Traister
- “Towards Healthier Science and Health News Feeds: NewsQ Panel on Science and Health Journalism” by Caroline Chen, Randi Hutter Epstein, Jennifer Kahn, Katherina Thomas, Rick Weiss, Wudan Yan, and Yemile Bucay
NewsQ has collected two types of information: potential “signals” of quality related to journalism and examples of feed results from platform news products. We work with our collaboration partner Knowledge Futures Group who maintains much of this data.
API. As of 2020, the NewsQ Database contains over 100 units of information on over 12,000 news and information sites. Some of these units of information may be potential “signals” of quality journalism. This database, which is mostly focused on English-language US readership, is currently open for testing purposes to a limited number of invited researchers and participants.
Feed results. Our project has collected specific results from news feeds across major platform news products by Google, Facebook, Twitter, Apple, and Microsoft for an initial qualitative review during our 2020 panels. The dataset, gathered across dates from February to June 2020, provides an illustrative rather than systematically sampled view of possible results. In addition to screenshots of news feed results, the results are accessible in an Airtable with additional contextual information about each of the top five articles, including the article URL.
In addition, in 2021, a dataset of results from Google News, Microsoft News, and Twitter Explore was also collected for analysis.
News within online information networks. This gap analysis on vaccine safety information on English Wikipedia began in 2020 and will be further developed in 2021, as well as analyzed for its handling of news sources.
- Orientation Guide on Algorithms and News Ranking: an orientation to help newcomers to algorithms understand the challenge of news ranking and recommendation systems better.
- Orientation Guide to Platform News Products: Provides overviews for eight news products, mostly from the perspective of the goals expressed by platform owners themselves, with background and process for each product (vis-a-vis news).
- Reference Guide: News Genre: Includes examples of classification systems, including Opinion.
- “Journalistic Values and Expertise in Platform News Distribution: The possibilities and limitations of participatory panels for algorithmic governance” (DOI) (Accepted Manuscript): This forthcoming paper in Journalism Studies by Connie Moon Sehat describes the methodology of the NewsQ panels project, as well as outlines future challenges.
- News Quality in the Platform Era: Research writings from a NewsQ-supported Social Science Research Council workshop are forthcoming in 2022 by Routledge.
It’s a work in progress, but here is our Zotero-powered library of relevant reading materials if you are interested in browsing. Suggestions for additions welcome.